
Vegan Personal Trainer's Tips on Weight Loss & Protein Intake
|
Dear Vegan at Heart,
This week your mission is to say yes to food discipline and no to the protein myth.
At its most elemental, losing weight is a math problem:
Eat less + exercise more = lower body fat
As a result, when I encounter a client seeking to trim down, I don't automatically lead with my veganism. Instead, I suggest portion control. Let's face it, just about every American eats more food than she/he needs. This unfortunate reality presents us with a fortunate opportunity: Cutting portion size just may be the easiest first step toward better health--both physical and psychological.
I say this because reducing our food portions is a huge move toward developing food discipline. The satisfaction that results from taking control of our eating habits makes it easier to continue making adjustments. Smaller portions--combined with increased physical activity--will provide the ultimate motivation: lower body fat and higher energy. This creates a triple dose of confidence:
*Developing self-control
*Losing weight
*Feeling more energetic
Once you've exercised the discipline to eat less and have felt the subsequent physical results, you'll find it less daunting to move on to addressing the quality of your meals, for example:
*Replace processed foods with healthier whole foods
*Cut out refined sugars and try eating more fresh fruit
*Then, of course, the ultimate goal: Move away from meat and dairy and instead opt for plant-based foods
As you feel and look better and better, the likelihood of turning back becomes negligible. In fact, the worst you may have to deal with will be all the questions from those in your life. There's one query I can guarantee you'll hear over and over: Where do you get your protein? This question is borne of the protein myth so let's put it to rest right here and now:
The typical American adult ingests 100 grams of protein every day, roughly four to five times the amount recommended by scientists not affiliated with meat and dairy corporations. How did we develop this idea that more is better when it comes to protein?
One reason is the indefensible institution of animal experimentation. Since trying to discern biological trends from human to human is often impossible, what makes us think testing done on a rat will lead to any knowledge about our anatomy and physiology? The breast milk of rats, for example, derives nearly half of its calories from protein. Human breast milk is 5.9% protein. Obviously, there's little useful information to be gained from monitoring the protein needs of rodents. However, many of today's "experts" are still relying on protein requirement studies done by Osborn and Mendel on rats...in 1914.
What about those who believe we need extra protein if we want to run faster, jump higher, or build larger muscles? As reported by Reed Mangels, Ph.D., R.D.: "Athletic performance is actually improved by a high carbohydrate diet, not a high protein diet." In addition, the mainstream National Academy of Sciences has declared, "There is little evidence that muscular activity increases the need for protein."
So, how much protein do we need? The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition says 2.5% of our daily calories should come from protein. According to the World Health Organization, it's about 5%. How does that work out in grams? A lot lower than the U.S. average of 100 grams a day, that's for sure.
"An adult male on a fast only puts out 4.32 grams of urinary nitrogen per day," says William Harris, M.D., author of The Scientific Basis for Vegetarianism. "Each gram represents 6.25 grams of broken down protein, so under conditions in which some protein is actually being catabolized and used for fuel, only about 4.32 x 6.25 = 27 grams/day are actually needed." Twenty-seven grams.
Which brings us to back human breast milk. Humans undergo their most rapid growth during infancy and human breast milk has evolved over hundreds of thousands of years to become the perfect food to facilitate that growth. As stated earlier, it derives only 5.9% of its calories from protein. So, if we need less than 6% of our calories from protein during a time of intense growth, why are we consuming so much more protein as full-grown adults?
One more thing: Let's take a minute to discuss the food combining/complete proteins myth. Since it's really amino acids and not protein our bodies require, many on the animal-eating front try to downplay plant proteins as being "incomplete."
This is yet again based on obsolete research that designates the egg as the "perfect" protein. However, even the conventional British medical journal, The Lancet, has declared: "Formerly, vegetable proteins were classified as second-class, and regarded as inferior to first-class proteins of animal origin, but this distinction has now been generally discarded." (By the way, the egg is perfect for one thing: producing a baby chick.)
The truth is, meeting protein requirements is more about calories than food combinations. If you're eating only from the "four food groups" of veganism you are guaranteed enough protein. These new four food groups are:
*Vegetables: 3 or more servings (a variety of green, yellow, and orange, including juicing)
*Whole Grains: 5 or more servings (bread, rice, pasta, cereal, etc.)
*Fruit: 3 or more servings (that's whole fruits and their juices)
*Legumes: 2 or more servings (beans, peas, lentils, plus: nuts and seeds)
More about Mickey:
Mickey Z. is probably the only person on the planet to have appeared in both a karate flick with Billy "Tae Bo" Blanks and a political book with Howard Zinn. He is the author of 9 books--most recently Self Defense for Radicals. Mickey Z. also works as a personal trainer, self-defense instructor, and urban health coach and can be reached at mickey@mickeyz.net.
|
More than one way to skin a carrot Thanks, Molly, for sharing your insight and experience. I definitely agree that fear of hunger can be a deterrent, and I've met many newbie vegans who are blown away by how much more food they can eat. But I've also run across a few who complain about having to eat more food to feel full. So I don't think it's stupid to get people to lessen their food intake first just so that they get used to feeling not quite so full all the time, have more energy, and start to see results. Then they can take it to the next level, as Mickey suggests, with fewer complaints. I guess there's more than one way to skin a carrot? :-) |
| Marisa (Wed, 30 Jun, 2010) |
|
I think he's got it backwards While I agree with Mickey that most Americans eat way too much food, I think he's approaching the transition from the wrong angle. When beginning a diet, what people dread is the lack of food. They fear going hungry. When I began eating a whole-food, plant-based, unprocessed diet, I found that I could eat a much larger volume of food because I was no longer consuming empty calories. I think this is the selling point to get people to transition to a healthy, plant-based diet, rather than the other way around. Teach them that they can eat more food and still lose weight, and that the food will be delicious and better for them, and they will jump on the bandwagon – I did! |
| Molly (Tue, 29 Jun, 2010) |